Deportation to Third Countries
The practice of deporting aliens with final orders of removal to third countries appears to be percolating through the appellate labyrinth of the federal courts to review by the United States Supreme Court.
Specifically, the United States Supreme Court, in favor of the Department of Homeland Security (“DHS”), stayed the April 18, 2025, preliminary injunction of the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts, case No. 25–cv– 10676, pending disposition of the appeal in the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit and disposition of a petition for writ of certiorari, if such writ is timely sought. See United States Supreme Court Order No. 24A1153; Department of Homeland Security et al. v. D. V. D. et al. (C. A. 1st Cir., June 23, 2025) Application for stay.
There was a time as recent as the 1980s when the subject of immigration law rarely appeared in the news. Furthermore, the subject of immigration law did not commonly appear in law school curriculums. You might say that it appeared to be completely under the radar. Now multiple news articles, broadcasts and podcasts about immigration law flood the news daily, like rain during a subtropical rainy season.
It seems fair to presume that many members of the American public associate apprehension and detention of individuals with police actions based on probable cause to believe the targeted individuals are criminal law violators for the purpose of punishing and rehabilitating such individuals. Thus, the apprehension and detention of individuals for the purpose of civil immigration law enforcement are sometimes confounded with the enforcement of criminal laws by police authorities.
Physical apprehension and detention of aliens who are in the United States without permission (i.e. without lawful immigration status) and aliens who are seeking admission to the United States without required documents or without inspection by an immigration officer are enforcement actions necessary to effectively remove such persons from the United States if such aliens are not eligible for relief from removal.
An alien in the United States without lawful immigration status is subject to arrest and detention solely based on such alien’s lack of lawful immigration status for the purpose of removing such alien from the United States. No criminal violation or charge is required. Likewise, no person who is not a United States citizen or national has an unfettered right to enter (or even transit through) the United States. See section 235(a)(3) of the Immigration Act, as amended ("the Act").
Turning to the enforcement of final removal orders to third countries, it might help to review the legal history of this enforcement directive.
As a matter of law, deportation to third countries is nothing new. The Immigration Act of 1917 provided:
That the deportation of aliens . . . shall be directed by the Attorney General to the country specified by the alien, if it is willing to accept him into its territory; otherwise such deportation shall be directed by the Attorney General within his discretion and without priority of preference because of their order as herein set forth, either to the country from which such alien last entered the United States; or to the country in which is located the foreign port at which such alien embarked for the United States or for foreign contiguous territory; or to any country in which he resided prior to entering the country from which he entered the United States; or to the country which had sovereignty over the birth-place of the alien at the time of his birth; or to any country of which such an alien is a subject, national, or citizen; or to the country in which he was born; or to the country in which the place of his birth is situated at the time he is ordered deported; or, if deportation to any of the said foregoing places or countries is impracticable, inadvisable, or impossible, then to any country which is willing to accept such alien into its territory.
. . .
No alien shall be deported under any provisions of this Act to any country in which the Attorney General shall find that such alien would be subject to physical persecution.
[emphasis added]
See section 20(a) of the Immigration Act of 1917.
In short, the Immigration Act of 1917:
- Allows the deportee to designate the country of to which he will be deported.
- Allows for deportation to alternative places when the country designated by the deportee will not accept the deportee into its territory.
- Allows the government to ultimately deport a deportee to any country which is willing to accept such person into its territory if deportation to any of the other specified alternative places is “impracticable, inadvisable, or impossible.”
- Prohibits deportation to any country in which the Attorney General finds that the deportee would be subject to physical persecution.
Congress repealed the Immigration Act of 1917 along with all other existing immigration acts and consolidated the immigration law under one act by enacting the Immigration and Nationality Act of June 27, 1952 (“1952 Act”).
Congress then carried forward and incorporated the Act of 1917 provisions relating to places to which deportees will be deported in section 243(a), (b) and (h) of the 1952 Act in slightly more detail. For example, with regard to a deportee’s option to designate a country for deportation, section 254(a) of the 1952 Act states:
The deportation of an alien . . . shall be directed by the Attorney General to a country promptly designated by the alien if that country is willing to accept him into its territory, unless the Attorney General, in his discretion, concludes that deportation to such country would be prejudicial to the interests of the United States. No alien shall be permitted to make more than one such designation, nor shall any alien designate . . . any foreign territory contiguous to the United States or any island adjacent thereto or adjacent to the United States unless such alien is a native, citizen, subject, or national of, or had a residence in such designated foreign contiguous territory or adjacent island. If the government of the country designated by the alien fails finally to advise the Attorney General within three months following original inquiry whether that government will or will not accept such alien into its territory, such designation may thereafter be disregarded.
The 1952 Act currently serves as the framework of United States immigration law, as amended by subsequent immigration acts, most notably the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 (“IIRIRA”), and implemented treaties. In short, the 1952 Act, as amended (“the Act”) preserves the provisions for countries and places of removal of the Immigration Act of 1917 in great detail. See sections 241(b)(1), (2) and (3) of the Act.
The provisions for the United States Attorney General’s direction of country or place of deportation under the provisions of 241(b) of the Act often give rise to third country deportations when an application for asylum under section 208 of the Act or the grant or denial of withholding of removal under section 241(b)(3) of the Act or the grant or denial of withholding of removal under Article 3 of the Convention Against Torture (“CAT”). See 8 C.F.R. § 1208.16(c) (not to be confused with withholding of removal under section 241(b)(3) of the Act).
In these types of cases based on alleged punishment or harm or torture in the country or place from which the applicant is fleeing, the applicant’s country of birth, citizenship, nationality or residence might not be possible or practicable.
This circumstance gives rise to the government’s consideration of alternative countries and places, including “third countries” for deportation.
For clarity, it should be noted that, even if an Immigration Judge grants an application for withholding of removal under section 241(b)(3) or Article 3 of CAT, the applicant continues to be subject to a removal order. Attorneys who successfully obtain a grant of withholding of removal for a client are sometimes surprised when the Immigration Judge also orders their client removed to a country other than the country where the risk of persecution or torture exists. A grant of withholding of removal, including CAT relief, is country specific and the DHS can remove an alien who has been granted withholding of removal or CAT relief by following the alternative approach described in sections 241(b)(1) and (2) of the Act. See 8 C.F.R. §§ 241.15 and 241.25.
During the 35 years that I had worked for the federal government I had never personally heard of an actual removal to a third country after a grant of withholding of removal. It appears that the main reason aliens granted withholding of removal were rarely removed to a third country was the inability or lack of motivation of the government to find or arrange for another country that would accept such aliens.
In summary, third country deportation, as a matter of law, is nothing new. Rather, the executive branch of government seeems currently motivated to use all of the tools in its tool box to effect deportation of aliens with final removal orders.
It seems, therefore, that the legal challenge to third country deportations will likely target the government’s procedures (i.e. how it applied the alternative removal options under section 241(b) of the Act) as opposed to whether third country deportations are based on substantive law.